Emily Garside on Russell T Davies’s urgent, unsettling & suitably messy queer rallying cry Tip Toe

There is little subtlety about Russell T Davies’s latest drama Tip Toe, which opens with Alan Cumming’s character Leo swinging from a Manchester lamppost. But rather than a critique, it suggests the time for subtlety may be over. This tense thriller’s message is that urgency, or else, is the agenda now. Leo’s fate is a stark ‘or else’ warning. 

Of course, Davies has never tiptoed around. The man who burst onto the Queer TV scene and into living rooms with a rimming scene mere moments into Queer as Folk has always said what he has to say loudly and proudly, but with urgency. And if the rimming in Queer as Folk was in defiance of a TV landscape and a society that refused to see the community of Canal Street (and beyond), some 30 years on the jarring murder at the opening of Tip Toe is a demand to be heard as the tide has shifted once again for the LGBTQ+ community. That late 90s demand for visibility has morphed into new fears as we confront new prejudices. As Melba (Paul Rhys), a long-time Canal Street stalwart, says to Alan Cumming’s bar owner Leo, “I used to walk into rooms and go, ‘ta-daa!’ Now I walk on tiptoe in case I get seen.” 

Paul Rhys in Russell T Davies’s Tip Toe on Starz. Photo credit: James Stack/Starz.

The debate over being seen, and its perils, is at the heart of Davies’s latest state of the (Queer) nation. And it’s an interesting question for him to pose, given his own role in the community being seen. While this is not a Queer as Folk sequel in a traditional TV sense, it is both its spiritual successor, a ‘state of the (queer) nation’ three decades on, and the world that Tip Toe comments on is, in part, a post-Queer as Folk world. It’s not some Doctor Who-esque metaverse suggesting Russell T Davies’s impact on the world; it’s more a thread woven into the fabric of Tip Toe. Not, as detractors of Davies would say, an egotistical move, but a genuine set of questions about the visibility of Queer folks: in media, online, in the public eye, and the subsequent interrogation of, and demonisation of, our identities. The community’s visibility comes in part through TV, which Queer as Folk helped produce. The show questions the monster the community has made itself—visibility—but at what cost? And it’s impossible to separate the writer and his work from that.

The show’s approach is worlds away from Queer as Folk, aside from its Manchester/Canal Street setting. Structured as a thriller, we see the end coming in, and spend the following five episodes finding out how we got there. Moving from comedy—as Leo gets locked out of his house while chasing an errant one-night stand down the street—despite the foreboding opening, we think we’re in for a campy queer drama, albeit with a with dark ending. But when Leo’s neighbour Clive is introduced, played by David Morrissey with an unsettling air of danger, it’s clear this is something else. Some hate the ‘end at the beginning’ format. Still, it works here: you know what’s coming, then you watch the moments leading up to the inevitable unravel as things grow increasingly tense and unsettling across the five episodes. 

Alan Cumming and David Morrissey in Russell T Davies’s Tip Toe on Starz. Photo credit: James Stack/Starz.

It’s significant that the person who dies is a cis white middle-class gay man of around 60 years old. Not simply because Davies himself is a cis white middle-class gay man of around 60 years old and therefore writing from his point of view—something he often gets criticised for—but that has often led to his strongest work (see Queer as Folk and later Cucumber). Leo—the cis, white, older middle-class man with the nice house—being brutally murdered adds a darker undertone to Davies’s message: this is who we expect to be safe, and even he isn’t. So if someone like Leo is in danger, what about the more vulnerable people in the community? Davies deliberately populates this story with more vulnerable queer folks including trans actors and characters. Leo employs and helps many younger queer folks in his bar, and the story weaves in that community element of looking after your own. Which makes it even more chilling when those very people Leo has helped to keep safe witness his terrible death, equally helpless to save him. 

Certain tabloids—the same ones that came for Davies’s Doctor Who work—will likely accuse him of tokenistic “woke” representation. But it accurately represents Canal Street in 2026 and these trans folks and the younger queer folks without support systems, are more vulnerable than Leo on a day-to-day basis. He even talks about three young men he knew dying by suicide. Leo talks about the additional security he now needs. We see Leo, the older gay man, wary of the danger that others around him are in; we assume that he is safer than they are, and yet by showing the ‘safest’ of the queer characters being brutally murdered, Davies drives home his point: nobody feels safe anymore; nobody is safe. Leo and his longtime friend Melba remember times gone by that were, ironically, probably safer than the era we find ourselves in.

David Morrissey and Alan Cumming in Russell T Davies’s Tip Toe on Starz. Photo credit: James Stack/Starz.

Leo and Clive’s story is ultimately unsettling because there’s no real ‘why’. The act of violence is, in fact, not premeditated, in the sense that Clive doesn’t sit and plot the murder we know (or are pretty sure) he has committed. Dramatically, it’s the brilliance of the writing. We expect a dark plot to murder the ‘gay next door’ because that makes sense: the idea of bad people plotting bad things. What happens though, is a snap decision. Mob mentality leads to Leo’s barbaric end. In many ways, it’s easier to reconcile a serial killer neighbour than to entertain the idea that the man next door can rewire your fuse box one day and be responsible for your murder the next. Politically, too, it’s a jarring commentary; it’s not the serial killers, the people we think we know are ‘bad men’, who we need to fear; it’s the man next door, and his friends on a random Saturday afternoon. 

That’s what Davies does best: he brings ideas close to home, literally. Leo tries to get along with his neighbour, because that’s what you do. Leo tries to help the young lad next door like he’s helped the young kids who come into his bar, because that’s what you do. The drama in a Davies story often centres on the kitchen, where the small dramas inside a house add up to the bigger picture. In Tip Toe, one minute, Leo is eating leftover party buffet food in his own kitchen only to be chased down by a lynch mob in Clive’s kitchen the next.

David Morrissey in Russell T Davies’s Tip Toe on Starz. Photo credit: James Stack/Starz.

It is the culmination of an array of typically persuasive Davies monologues. Sweeping speeches on politics, debates over online culture, police in queer spaces, drag queens who are teachers and more. All the politics, all the debate, comes down to a series of events inside two homes. That culmination is a fascinating choice. It comes down to Clive’s wife, Marie (Pooky Quesnel), looking away at the wrong time. She shuts herself away in the bedroom, understandably sick of the way her husband is behaving, and the chaos currently in her kitchen with the ‘lads’ round watching football. But she was the only person who could have saved Leo in that moment, but Davies has her upstairs, headphones in, deliberately shutting out what’s going on downstairs. Not because she is complicit in what they’re doing, but because that’s what people do: they shut out the noise of the world, often to the detriment of people who need their help. 

Marie looking away at exactly the wrong moment sums up what’s at the core of Tip Toe. The belief that people like Leo, that the LGBTQ+ community, no longer needs protecting. Indeed, maybe the opposite. The ever-pervasive idea that somehow the LGBTQ+ community are calling the shots. The way Marie is hiding—quite literally—from what goes on in her own home as Leo is murdered makes the point that the community doesn’t have the power, and that looking away in itself can, quite literally, be lethal. Marie doesn’t intentionally look away to harm Leo, she does it to protect herself.

Alan Cumming and David Morrissey in Russell T Davies’s Tip Toe on Starz. Photo credit: James Stack/Starz.

The story works as well as a thriller as it does as a political tirade. The ‘end-at-the-beginning’ structure might turn some people off, but the journey to getting to that point is the story. It’s written with enough tense twists and turns that you sometimes question what’s true and what isn’t. After each episode, you’re left rethinking who or what is to blame for where we know we are inevitably going. Knowing the endpoint doesn’t dilute the tension, and when it comes it remains shocking. It might feel exaggerated—a dramatisation—but Davies is asking, ‘How far are we from this really?’ and the answer is, not very.

Thousands of words could be written in praise of the performances in this series. Alan Cumming and David Morrissey should be up for as many awards as possible. Cumming gives, it’s fair to say, a performance of a lifetime as Leo. In the supporting cast, Rhys’ acerbic-but-on-the-money Canal Street stalwart Melba is perfection and Charlie Condou, in brief but impactful scenes as Leo’s ex-husband Curtis, is a standout. Clive’s wife Marie could be unsympathetic in the wrong actor’s hands, but Quesnel unravels the woman’s worn-down fatigue, making us understand how everyone can sometimes look the other way to make their own life marginally easier. 

Alan Cumming in Russell T Davies’s Tip Toe on Starz. Photo credit: James Stack/Starz.

Synthesising the political landscape that Tip Toe depicts is an ambitious task for five episodes. The kind of ambition Davies has shown in other later works, from Years and Years, where speculative sci-fi meets current political analysis, to It’s a Sin, which distills the trauma, politics, and human stories of the height of the HIV/AIDS epidemic in the UK into just five hours of television. Queer history and politics are notoriously complex and nuanced, and distilling them into a drama series is a tall order. Tip Toe captures much about the current state of things, as we are living through it. Taking in rising fears about violence against queer folks, the collapse of the queer community, online radicalisation, generational divide and hatred stoked by right-wing bigotry. Davies examines the cumulative impact of all these dangers, which appear equally concerning. The result is potent. An urgent, unsettling, suitably messy, queer rallying cry coupled with an apt sense of despair.

By Emily Garside

All episodes of Tip Toe are now streaming on STARZ in the US and on Channel 4 in the UK.

Tip Toe | Official Trailer | STARZ
Tip Toe | Official Poster | STARZ

Leave a Reply

Up ↑